Dodo Bird Verdict in Psychotherapy
The Dodo Bird Verdict
The Dodo bird is a now extinct species of flightless bird that once inhabited the island of Mauritius. It was actually a pretty big bird, roughly 50 pounds in weight, with a 9-inch bill. Around 1507, Portuguese sailors first spotted this bird and in less than 200 years man, and the animals he brought to the island, completely wiped out the animal.
![]() |
This bird was part of Alice's Adventures in Wonderland, where its character essentially declared that everyone wins and everyone gets a prize after a race. Inasmuch, the Dodo Bird Verdict, introduced by psychologist Saul Rosenzweig, basically states that the more than 500 different kinds of psychotherapies are equally effective.
Is this true? Let's explore this topic a bit more in depth.
Is the Verdict Really True? Yes
The basis for the Dodo Bird Verdict is that it doesn't matter whether or not behavior therapy, psychodynamic therapy, cognitive therapy, or some other therapy altogether is used to help a person. The real meat behind the recovery process for the patient, is that the patient has the opportunity to talk to a skilled professional with a sympathetic ear and that he is willing to follow the directions his psychotherapist gives him in order to help him recover.
Is this true? While some research studies do seem to show that a particular kind of psychotherapy is superior to another, many of these studies have actually been conducted by proponents of that 'superior' therapy technique, making others question whether the study was truly impartial.
Other studies, going back to at least the 1970s, have shown all therapies to work equally well. In fact, in 1997 another study about this was conducted by psychologist Bruce Wampold. It analyzed more than 200 scientific studies, with respect to this question, and found that if there was a difference in one mainstream therapy's effectiveness over another, it was minimal.
If this is indeed true, if all therapies are equally effective, why is this the case? Well, look at lions, tigers, and domestic cats. They all look different but you'll agree they all share common core features. For instance, they're carnivores, they have very sharp teeth, and they all have a not-so-hidden contempt for inferior species, like humans.
And so one explanation for the Dodo Bird Verdict is that, in the end, all these different types of psychotherapies have common core features and that's why they're essentially equally effective. What are these core features? I sort of hinted at them before. They are:
- A therapist with skill
- A sympathetic (or empathetic) therapist
- A close rapport between the therapist and patient
- Common therapeutic goals
These core features essentially trump any superficial differences between the varying therapies.
Are We Sure the Verdict Is Really True? Not Necessarily
But we have to be careful here. There is always another side to the story. Even Wampold noted in his research that his conclusions do not extend to all of the more than 500 therapies around today. His research mainly focused on therapies that have been shown to have sound psychological principles in various publications.
Additionally, some research has shown that even when we look solely at the accepted therapies, the ones based on sound principles, the type of treatment may matter under specific circumstances. As an example, it has been shown that behavior therapy and cognitive-behavior therapy can be more effective than most other therapies for things like anxiety disorders. Furthermore, some widely used therapies have been shown to actually hurt patients, as opposed to help them.
So what's the final verdict on the Dodo? We know the real bird is extinct. But is this one? The end result is that common core elements we went over before are important across any therapy technique, but specific nuances may influence how effective one therapy technique is for one person vs. another depending on their actual problem.
Lesson Summary
The Dodo bird is a now extinct species of flightless bird. The Dodo Bird Verdict arose as a result of this bird's use as a character in Alice's Adventures in Wonderland, where the character stated everyone wins after a race. Saul Rosenzweig used this notion to basically state all psychotherapy techniques are equally effective. While a lot of research supports this notion in general, because all effective psychotherapy techniques encompass key core principals, other research suggests the problem a person has (the extent and duration of that problem), and other specifics may influence how effective one psychotherapy technique is over another.
The key principles psychotherapeutic techniques have, include;
- A therapist with skill
- A sympathetic (or empathetic) therapist
- A close rapport between the therapist and patient
- Common therapeutic goals
To unlock this lesson you must be a Study.com Member.
Create your account
Register to view this lesson
Unlock Your Education
See for yourself why 30 million people use Study.com
Become a Study.com member and start learning now.
Become a MemberAlready a member? Log In
BackDodo Bird Verdict in Psychotherapy
Related Study Materials
- TExES Science of Teaching Reading (293): Practice & Study Guide
- Next Gen NCLEX-PN Study Guide & Practice
- Next Gen NCLEX-RN Study Guide & Practice
- TExES Core Subjects EC-6 (391): Practice & Study Guide
- TExES School Counselor (252): Practice & Study Guide
- Multithreading, Networking & Machine Learning in Python
- Digital Forensics
- The Internet of Things and Networking
- Network Routing and Switching
- Virtual Servers and Networking
- How to Pick Your Homeschool Curriculum
- Role of Student Support in Open & Distance Learning
- TExES Principal Exam Redesign (068 vs. 268)
- Teacher Salary by State
- ESL Resource Guide for Teachers
- What is a Homeschool Co-op?
- How to Start Homeschooling Your Children
Latest Courses
- Chemical Nomenclature & Notation
- Factors Impacting Family & Consumer Sciences
- Heritability Coefficient
- Major Health Problems in the United States
- Task-Centered Approaches in Social Work
- Asymmetric Induction: Definition, Factors & Methods
- Termination of Services in Social Work: Ethical & Legal Issues
- Quiz & Worksheet - Types of Personality Disorders
- What are Dinosaurs Related to? - Quiz & Worksheet for Kids
- Finding a Character's Emotions by Actions: Quiz & Worksheet for Kids
- Quiz & Worksheet - Memory Hole in 1984
- Flashcards - Real Estate Marketing Basics
- Flashcards - Promotional Marketing in Real Estate
- Responsible Decision-Making Teaching Resources
- 1st Grade Math Worksheets & Printables
Latest Lessons
- Introduction to Educational Psychology: Certificate Program
- Precalculus: Certificate Program
- AP Biology: Tutoring Solution
- Western Civilization I: Help and Review
- Spanish 101: Beginning Spanish
- ACT Math: Number & Quantity
- Experimental Design
- Quiz & Worksheet - The Path-Goal Theory & Leadership Styles
- Quiz & Worksheet - Calculating the Probability of Permutations
- Quiz & Worksheet - Constructing an Angle Bisector
- Quiz & Worksheet - Properties of Cylinders
- Quiz & Worksheet - Lack of Consideration in a Contract
Popular Courses
- Parties in an Assignment: Rights of the Assignee, Assignor & Obligor
- How to Find 24 Factorial
- How to Write an Appeal Letter for College
- Prohibition Lesson Plan
- How to Ace Your Job Interview
- Best GMAT Prep Course
- Best MCAT Prep Books
- Solar System Project Ideas
- Is the FTCE General Knowledge Test Hard?
- MCAT Registration Information
- Essay Writing Prompts
- How to Go to College for Free
Popular Lessons
Math
Social Sciences
Science
Business
Humanities
Education
History
Art and Design
Tech and Engineering
- Tech and Engineering - Videos
- Tech and Engineering - Quizzes
- Tech and Engineering - Questions & Answers