Chris has a master's degree in history and teaches at the University of Northern Colorado.
Equal Rights Amendment: Definition, History, Pros & Cons
Equality for All
In the twenty-first century, the idea of an equality amendment seems like something from history. The consensus amongst contemporary Americans is that equality is a given. So you may be surprised to know that something called the Equal Rights Amendment has never been added to the United States Constitution.
The Equal Rights Amendment was a proposed amendment to the US Constitution to guarantee equal rights for women and outlaw discrimination based on sex. It was first proposed in 1923 and passed both houses of Congress in 1972, but failed to achieve 3/4 ratification by the states. Although many states have since adopted an equal rights amendment into state constitutions, this amendment is not part of the United States Constitution.
In 1920, the 19th Amendment was ratified and added to the United States Constitution, legally giving women the right to vote. The major suffragist leader Alice Paul celebrated the victory by taking the next step and drafting an amendment that would make all discrimination based on sex illegal. In 1923, her Equal Rights Amendment was introduced to Congress, after being tested and adopted by the state of Wisconsin in 1921. The amendment was wrapped up in political and legal battles for years, finally being voted on (and defeated) in 1946.
In 1958, President Dwight Eisenhower was the first president to actively support the Equal Rights Amendment, and asked Congress to pass it. One of the big problems was the Hayden Rider, an addition made in 1953 which granted established women as a separate category from men in terms of legal rights and criminal action. The Hayden Rider granted women rights, but only as a separate legal group, undermining the idea of equality. Congress was willing to pass the Equal Rights Amendment with the Hayden Rider, but women's rights groups were not.
The Equal Rights Amendment was supported and opposed by a wide array of people. Eleanor Roosevelt, for example, opposed the bill because she felt that women's rights had to be addressed as a class issue first, and that the amendment only benefited middle class women. Esther Peterson, the highest-ranking woman in JFK's administration, opposed it for fear that it would weaken labor rights movements of the time and a general opposition to blanket policies, preferring a 'specific bills for specific ills' approach to equal rights. Eleanor Roosevelt later changed her mind in the 1960s and said that unionization had resolved the class issue and the amendment was now safe for women. Betty Ford, First Lady and wife of President Gerald Ford, became a vocal and active supporter of the Equal Rights Amendment.
Congress vs. States
A series of protests and strikes in 1970 led Congress to re-address the Equal Rights Amendment. In 1972, it finally passed both the Senate and House of Representatives in a format that women's rights advocates agreed with. Now, 3/4 of the states had to ratify, or approve, the amendment to make it a legal addition to the United States Constitution. By 1973, 30 states had done so. The ratification had to occur by 1979 or the amendment expired, and as the deadline approached they were 3 states short. 5 states had also rescinded, or retracted, their original decision to ratify. The legality of these has been debated ever since. Supporters of the amendment did manage to get the deadline extended to 1982, but still fell short of the 3/4 number needed to adopt the amendment
Throughout the 1980s and 90s, the Equal Rights Amendment was debated mostly on grounds of traditional gender roles; i.e. men make money and women raise children. Conservative opponent Phyllis Schlafly was one of the most prominent figures in this debate, and gained tremendous support to keep the Equal Rights Amendment out of the Constitution during the 1980s. 1983 was the last time the Equal Rights Amendment made it to the floor of Congress for a vote, falling 6 votes short of passing. In 1993, supporters of the amendment publicly stated that Congress should repeal the time limit and hold the 35 original states to their ratifications, meaning that only three more states need to ratify the amendment for it to pass. Three states of the original 15 has, as of 2022, ratified the ERA: Illinois, Nevada, and Virginia.
The Equal Rights Amendment is a proposed amendment to the United States Constitution that guarantees equal rights for women. It was first proposed by the suffragist, supporter of women's rights to vote, Alice Paul in 1923. However, it failed to pass. Later, in an attempt to gain more Congressional support, the Hayden Rider was added, an addition that limited the actual equality in the amendment by making men and women separate legal categories. This pushed away the amendment's original supporters. In 1973, the amendment was finally passed by both houses of Congress in terms that the original supporters agreed with. To become part of the US Constitution, 3/4 of the states needed to ratify it, but the deadline passed 3 states short. The Equal Rights Amendment is still not a part of the US Constitution, although 20 states have a similar feature in their own state constitutions.
To unlock this lesson you must be a Study.com Member.
Create your account
Register to view this lesson
Unlock Your Education
See for yourself why 30 million people use Study.com
Become a Study.com member and start learning now.Become a Member
Already a member? Log InBack
Resources created by teachers for teachers
I would definitely recommend Study.com to my colleagues. It’s like a teacher waved a magic wand and did the work for me. I feel like it’s a lifeline.