Back To CourseHistory 104: US History II
14 chapters | 111 lessons | 10 flashcard sets
As a member, you'll also get unlimited access to over 70,000 lessons in math, English, science, history, and more. Plus, get practice tests, quizzes, and personalized coaching to help you succeed.Free 5-day trial
Alexandra has taught students at every age level from pre-school through adult. She has a BSEd in English Education.
During the Second Industrial Revolution in America, workers needed help. First of all, modern labor laws such as safety regulations, minimum wages and working hours didn't exist at the federal level, and many state and local protections were struck down by the Supreme Court. There had been little need for economic regulation in earlier times and little desire to see federal intervention over states' rights until after the Civil War. This hands-off approach to the economy is called laissez-faire capitalism.
Second, in the late 1800s, many educated Americans agreed with the concept (if not the term) of social Darwinism; that is, the so-called 'fittest' members of society - in this case, the fittest businesses - will survive, and the weakest will die out. Therefore, the struggle between labor and management was only natural, and if it was allowed to play out, then the economy and the people would evolve into something stronger - at least in theory.
In reality, working conditions were not going to evolve, because labor had no leverage. This third problem was largely due to unprecedented immigration. Despite difficult, dangerous circumstances, there was an increasing pool of people willing to work for poverty wages, and when there are more willing workers than jobs, employers don't need to improve conditions.
Throughout Europe, many workers turned to various forms of socialism, but American workers weren't necessarily dissatisfied with government; they just wanted to increase their own bargaining position in the market. They did this by organizing. A factory owner could easily replace one button-pusher who complained about his working conditions; it was not so easy to replace an entire factory full of them.
The earliest large-scale union in the United States was the Knights of Labor, organized in 1869. They sought equal work for equal pay, including women and blacks, and an 8-hour workday. Despite early successes, however, the Knights peaked in the 1880s and were soon replaced by the American Federation of Labor, or simply the AFL.
The AFL, led by Samuel Gompers, combined several national craft unions in 1886. The American Federation of Labor saw modest victories, because they had modest goals. They did not attempt to overhaul the basic economic system. Instead, Gompers and the AFL pressed for a better position within the existing system: for example, higher wages, a right to work without being laid off arbitrarily and better working conditions. Gompers opposed most strikes and didn't think that organized labor should be involved in politics - though the AFL did come to support candidates after the turn of the century. And though Gompers claimed that unions were 'of the workers, by the workers, for the workers,' the American Federation of Labor did not welcome unskilled workers. They approved of racially segregated local unions and varied in their openness to women.
In contrast to the relatively docile AFL, the most militant of the early labor unions was the Industrial Workers of the World, known simply as the IWW, or 'Wobblies.' The Wobblies openly called for class warfare and aggression, including sabotage, and looked forward to the day when workers would seize machines and factories for themselves. Their leader, Eugene Debs, ran for president several times as the Socialist Party candidate.
Although strikes were not new in America, worker organization became more widespread during the Second Industrial Revolution. In the 1880s alone, there were nearly 10,000 strikes and lockouts. Of course, management attempted to shut down the growing union movement, tried to stop workers from joining unions and did whatever they could to break strikes. In many ways, the two sides were at war with one another, often with violent results. Usually, the workers ended up on the losing side.
One such conflict was the Great Railroad Strike of 1877. The nation was still feeling the effects of the Panic of 1873, with unemployment as high as 14%. When railroad employees in West Virginia had their pay cut twice in a matter of months, they went on strike, but railroad executives were unable or unwilling to discuss their demands. The strike spread to cities across the nation, leading to riots, arson, destruction of railroad property and even gun battles with state and federal troops. Before it was all over, more than 100 men were dead, and more than $100 million worth of property had been damaged. But, there were no increases in pay and the War Department created the National Guard to handle such problems in the future.
Nine years later, another nationwide strike was called, involving 340,000 workers from 12,000 different companies, all of whom were pushing for a standard 8-hour workday. Strikers rallied in cities across the country. In Chicago's Haymarket Square, police attempted to break up one such demonstration, organized by known anarchists. One of the strikers threw a bomb at police. They responded by firing into the crowd. Reports vary, but as many as 12 people were killed (including seven or eight police officers), and up to 60 people were injured. Ultimately, four of the organizers were hanged for their involvement. The Haymarket demonstration turned public opinion against the unions, who felt that they were becoming too radical and threatening law and order. Union membership fell dramatically in the years that followed.
Another infamous labor dispute took place at a Carnegie steel mill in Homestead, Pennsylvania, in 1892. As hundreds of Pinkerton detectives sailed up the river to break the strike, workers opened fire, killing at least seven of the Pinkertons and continuing to attack them even after their surrender. Then, they turned their anger against non-union employees who were willing to keep working, prompting the National Guard to get involved. Although the American public had been somewhat sympathetic toward the workers initially, that support waned and finally collapsed after a failed assassination attempt against the plant's COO. The strike was broken and unions were not welcome back in the plant for nearly 40 years.
The union movement was subdued even further by the 1894 Pullman Strike near Chicago. For almost 30 years, the company had made luxury railroad sleeper cars and required its workers to live in the so-called 'company town,' where the corporation owned and ran everything, including housing and food. So when wages at the Pullman Company were cut up to 40%, without any reduction in prices, workers went on strike in 1894. In their support, Eugene Debs and the IWW encouraged railroad workers around the country not to run any trains that had Pullman cars attached. But because those sidelined trains also pulled post office cars, the strike opened a perfect opportunity for the courts to step in, ordering an injunction against the unions for interfering with the mail. The predictable riots were quelled by the U.S. army, the strike organizers were put on trial, and Eugene Debs was imprisoned for conspiracy. It was an important precedent; the Pullman strike expanded the federal government's ability to intervene in labor disputes in the future.
Let's review. Many Americans during the Second Industrial Revolution felt that the government had no right to interfere with business. Many also accepted the idea of Social Darwinism, believing that 'survival of the fittest' applied not only to nature, but also to society. As a result, there was almost no legal protection for workers, and with record immigration, they had no leverage over management.
American workers turned in large numbers to labor unions to try to increase their bargaining power. One of the more successful unions was the American Federation of Labor, which worked to improve conditions for workers within the existing economic structure.
There were thousands of strikes and other union actions in this era, which were resisted fiercely by business owners and managers. After the Haymarket demonstration in Chicago, public opinion turned against the unions, believing they had become too radical. And after the Pullman Strike, also in Chicago, the federal government expanded its role in labor disputes.
After seeing this video lesson, you should be able to:
To unlock this lesson you must be a Study.com Member.
Create your account
Did you know… We have over 95 college courses that prepare you to earn credit by exam that is accepted by over 2,000 colleges and universities. You can test out of the first two years of college and save thousands off your degree. Anyone can earn credit-by-exam regardless of age or education level.
To learn more, visit our Earning Credit Page
Not sure what college you want to attend yet? Study.com has thousands of articles about every imaginable degree, area of study and career path that can help you find the school that's right for you.
Back To CourseHistory 104: US History II
14 chapters | 111 lessons | 10 flashcard sets