Kat has a Master of Science in Organizational Leadership and Management and teaches Business courses.
Transferred Intent for Assault and Battery
Transferred Intent
Suppose your neighbor's dog barks all night. At wit's end, you crawl out of bed, grab a rock and throw it in the dog's direction. Fortunately, for the dog, you do not have a very good aim. You bypassed the barking pooch, but the rock hits your neighbor instead.
You might say that you did not mean to hit the neighbor and refuse to pay for his injuries. However, the law will see it differently.
By tossing the rock toward the dog, you committed trespass to chattels. This means you attempted to interfere with another person's enjoyment of their personal property, the dog.
However, by missing the dog but hitting the neighbor instead, transferred intent occurred, and the liability shifted from the trespass to chattels - attempting to strike the dog - to battery against your neighbor.
If the following occurred, transferred intent is probably present:
- A tort would have been committed if contact with the original party occurred
- A tort was committed to an unintended party, resulting in damages
In a legal brief of high importance, we will learn that the law does not recognize intent when ruling on cases where an innocent victim becomes the target of assault and battery.

An error occurred trying to load this video.
Try refreshing the page, or contact customer support.
You must cCreate an account to continue watching
Register to view this lesson
As a member, you'll also get unlimited access to over 84,000 lessons in math, English, science, history, and more. Plus, get practice tests, quizzes, and personalized coaching to help you succeed.
Get unlimited access to over 84,000 lessons.
Try it nowAlready registered? Log in here for access
BackYou're on a roll. Keep up the good work!
Just checking in. Are you still watching?
Yes! Keep playing.Talmage v. Smith (Mich. 1894)
Although this case took place quite a long time ago, it substantially explains the doctrine of transferred intent.
Smith owned property in Michigan. On his property were several sheds. The sheds were a temptation to the local children.
Fed up with noise coming from the kids playing on the shed roofs, Smith confronted several of them and asked that they leave his property. A few left, and a few others remained.
Not satisfied, Smith returned to the area of his property where the sheds stood. He picked up a large stick and threw it at one of the boys - the first boy he saw, to be exact. As the first boy ducked from the projectile, another boy, named Talmage, was struck in the eye. The blow blinded him permanently.
In this case, the court saw the act of throwing the stick as an act of battery. Mostly because of the force it carried. The court also looked at the two criteria. Let us review:
- Smith intended to hit one of the boys with the stick (battery)
- Smith's intention to commit battery affected a bystander (battery)
To say it a simpler way, Smith intended to commit a battery upon one of the boys occupying his roof. The force he used to throw the stick proved this. He missed his intended target, which was determined to be the first child he saw. He did, in fact, hit an unintended target, causing severe injury and blindness.
The court ruled in favor of Talmage. Smith was liable for the injuries the boy sustained.
Lesson Summary
To sum things up, transferred liability occurs when one of the five torts was committed against an intended party but actually occurs to another party, like throwing a rock at your victim but it actually hitting an innocent bystander.
When this occurs, the law looks at a couple of things:
- A tort would have been committed if contact with the original party occurred
- A tort was committed to an unintended party resulting in damages
If both statements can be proven true, liability can also be proven.
In our landmark case, Talmage v. Smith, the defendant was held liable for his actions, even though it was not his intention to injure a third party.
Learning Outcomes
After you've completed this lesson, you'll be able to:
- Define transferred liability and transferred intent
- List the factors that must be met in order to find liability using transferred intent
- Summarize the facts and ruling of the case Talmage v. Smith
To unlock this lesson you must be a Study.com Member.
Create your account
Register to view this lesson
Unlock Your Education
See for yourself why 30 million people use Study.com
Become a Study.com member and start learning now.
Become a MemberAlready a member? Log In
BackTransferred Intent for Assault and Battery
Related Study Materials
- Effective Communication in the Workplace: Help and Review
- Business Law: Tutoring Solution
- Business Law: Help and Review
- Introduction to Business: Homework Help Resource
- Organizational Behavior: Help and Review
- Principles of Marketing: Certificate Program
- CLEP Information Systems: Study Guide & Test Prep
- Effective Communication in the Workplace: Certificate Program
- Information Systems: Help and Review
- CLEP Financial Accounting: Study Guide & Test Prep
- Introduction to Financial Accounting: Certificate Program
- UExcel Introduction to Macroeconomics: Study Guide & Test Prep
- Financial Accounting: Tutoring Solution
- Financial Accounting: Homework Help Resource
- Praxis Family & Consumer Sciences (5122): Practice & Study Guide
Browse by Courses
- What is GitHub?
- What is Multi-Task Learning?
- What Causes Segmentation Fault in C++?
- What is a Segmentation Fault?
- Action Statements: Definition & Examples
- Types of Automation Testing Tools
- What is Backend Development?
- Backend vs. Frontend Development
- What are Backend Programming Languages?
- Case Insensitive Programming Languages
- JavaScript TypeOf: Uses & Examples
- Machine Learning vs. Artificial Intelligence
- Machine Learning: Definition & Types
- Machine Learning: Techniques & Applications
- When to Use Static Methods in Java
Browse by Lessons
- General Science Lessons
- TExES Science of Teaching Reading (293): Practice & Study Guide
- Next Gen NCLEX-PN Study Guide & Practice
- Next Gen NCLEX-RN Study Guide & Practice
- TExES Core Subjects EC-6 (391): Practice & Study Guide
- Post World War II Events & Politics
- General Astronomy
- General Birds
- General Geography
- General Plants
- How to Register for the Pennsylvania Core Assessment Exam
- How to Pick Your Homeschool Curriculum
- Role of Student Support in Open & Distance Learning
- TExES Principal Exam Redesign (068 vs. 268)
- Teacher Salary by State
- ESL Resource Guide for Teachers
- What is a Homeschool Co-op?
Latest Courses
- What is Passover? - Definition, Story, Traditions & Significance
- Covered Wagon Facts & History: Lesson for Kids
- Asian Ethnic Groups
- Ancient Asian Literature & Poetry
- Jackal Characteristics & Mythology | What is a Jackal?
- Clinical Judgment Case Study - Patient Laboratory Test Management
- Jaguar Adaptations: Lesson for Kids
- Quiz & Worksheet - Political Satire
- Quiz & Worksheet - Systems of Communication
- Quiz & Worksheet - Sources & Benefits of Insoluble Fiber
- Quiz & Worksheet - Victimization Consequences
- Flashcards - Real Estate Marketing Basics
- Flashcards - Promotional Marketing in Real Estate
- Digital Citizenship | Curriculum, Lessons and Lesson Plans
- Rubrics | Rubric Definition and Types
Latest Lessons
- HiSET Social Studies: Prep and Practice
- Common Core ELA Grade 7 - Language: Standards
- 12th Grade English: Homework Help Resource
- AEPA Biology (NT305): Practice & Study Guide
- Veterinary Assistant Exam: Prep & Study Guide
- GRE Quantitative Reasoning - Numbers and Operations: Tutoring Solution
- Waves, Sound, and Light: Tutoring Solution
- Quiz & Worksheet - Properties of Metallic Bonds
- Quiz & Worksheet - Responsibilities of the European Commission
- Quiz & Worksheet - Using the Law of Cosines to Solve Oblique Triangles
- Quiz & Worksheet - Overview of Germany's Foreign Relations
- Quiz & Worksheet - Modern Atomic Theory & Theorists
Popular Courses
- How Compounds are Broken Down: Heat & Electricity
- Brazil's Textile Industry
- Washington State Science Standards
- Suicide Prevention Grants
- Math Bulletin Board Ideas
- Prohibition Lesson Plan
- Math Activities for Kids
- 3rd Grade Word Walls
- Ohio Science Standards for Grade 6
- ESL Reading Comprehension Tests
- Context Clues Lesson Plan
- 504 Plans in California
Popular Lessons
Math
Social Sciences
Science
Business
Humanities
Education
History
Art and Design
Tech and Engineering
- Tech and Engineering - Videos
- Tech and Engineering - Quizzes
- Tech and Engineering - Questions & Answers
Health and Medicine
Explore our library of over 84,000 lessons
- Create a Goal
- Create custom courses
- Get your questions answered