Wendy has taught all subjects of high school social studies and English and has a master's degree in Secondary Education.
Meeting a Public Defender: A Short Story
Resting his head on his hands, the young man looked up at the woman seated across the table from him. She was wearing a neatly pressed navy-blue suit and jotting notes on a legal pad.
'Mr. Anderson, my name is Kate Evans and I am with the Public Defender's Office. I have been appointed to represent you in your criminal case. Do you understand that you have been charged with drug possession and having an illegal weapon?'
'That stuff wasn't mine! I just dropped off a friend…' Joey Anderson stopped abruptly at the attorney's stern look.
'We'll discuss your defense later. At this time, I want to focus on your bail hearing,' she said calmly.
Joey felt a sense of panic. Bail? Who would post his bail? And could he trust this person? He had no money to pay her and wondered if she knew that.
'I don't have any money,' he muttered. 'How are you getting paid?'
Ms. Evans looked up. 'I'm sorry, I thought you understood that I am with the Public Defender's Office.'
'I've never heard of that,' Joey said. 'What exactly is a public defender?'
Ms. Evans replied, 'We are paid by the state. A public defender represents people accused of a crime who cannot afford a private attorney. Our office exists to make sure that everyone gets a fair trial. We think that justice should not be based on the amount of money you have.'
Joey looked skeptical. 'Are you a real lawyer?' he asked. He wondered why anyone who had gone through law school would work as a public defender. Why not make the big bucks in a fancy law firm?
Ms. Evans smiled. 'Yes, Mr. Anderson, I am a real lawyer. I passed the state bar exam with a high score,' she said. 'I even graduated in the top ten percent of my class. You can be assured that I am capable of representing you.'
Public Defenders: Qualified Attorneys With a Difficult But Rewarding Job
In spite of Joey's doubts, Ms. Evans is in fact a highly competent attorney. Like many public defenders, she believes in the work she does to make sure that everyone gets a fair trial. Ms. Evans enjoys the challenge of representing indigent defendants, those who cannot afford to pay for their own defense. Since she is in court on a daily basis, she knows other attorneys and judges well and uses this knowledge to skillfully advocate for her clients.
Public defenders are employed at the local, state, and federal levels. The government pays their salaries and expenses (although they do not have the same budget to spend on legal expenses that private clients can afford). Each jurisdiction determines who qualifies for a public defender based on the defendant's income and expenses.
Why Are Public Defenders Necessary?
Why does the government pay to defend those accused of a crime? The Constitution of the United States ensures everyone, including the poor, of the right to a fair trial. The Sixth Amendment of the Constitution states that in all criminal prosecutions, the accused will 'have the Assistance of Counsel for his defence.' Over time, the Supreme Court has ruled that this right is applied to the states through the 'due process' clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. One of the most significant decisions regarding this right to counsel (a qualified attorney) in criminal cases is Gideon v. Wainwright.
The Legal History of the Right to Counsel
In the Gideon case, Clarence Earl Gideon was accused of breaking and entering a pool hall in Florida and stealing money. He asked the trial judge to appoint him an attorney, since he could not afford one. The trial judge denied the request, saying that counsel (an attorney) only had to be provided for capital (death penalty) cases. Gideon was tried and had to represent himself. He was found guilty. He appealed his conviction to the Florida Supreme Court, which denied his petition and ruled that his rights were not violated. Gideon's next appeal was to the Supreme Court of the United States in 1963.
It's important to understand that the Supreme Court only reviews a very small percentage of cases that are presented to it. As the highest and final appeals court in the country, it is the last chance for justice in many cases. The court carefully selects cases that it believes have important constitutional issues that need clarification. They weigh carefully drafted briefs by highly trained attorneys and still only grant a writ of certiorari , a decision to review the case, a very small percentage of the time.
Continuing to act as his own attorney, Gideon submitted his handwritten petition to the Supreme Court. The court not only reviewed his case, but reversed the decision of the lower court! The Supreme Court ruled unanimously that the constitution guaranteed the right to counsel to represent defendants who could not afford an attorney. The court believed that it was impossible for a person to get a fair trial if he was forced to defend himself without an attorney to represent him.
Other cases since Gideon have affirmed the right to counsel for the accused not only in criminal trials, but in all phases of the legal process in which a person's freedom is at stake (for example, interrogations, line-ups, arraignments, and plea negotiations). Public defenders handle these legal matters for people who cannot afford private attorneys.
Public defenders often have heavy caseloads and inadequate resources. However, they are qualified attorneys who work hard to obtain justice for those who cannot afford to pay for an attorney. With public defenders available, the poor are not automatically left to defend themselves when they are faced with the accusation of a crime. A public defender is there to protect their legal rights at each step of the process, helping ensure that the justice system in the United States is fair to all.
To unlock this lesson you must be a Study.com Member.
Create your account
Register to view this lesson
Unlock Your Education
See for yourself why 30 million people use Study.com
Become a Study.com member and start learning now.Become a Member
Already a member? Log InBack