Test Optional Admissions: Benefiting Schools, Students, or Both?

Sep 01, 2011

According to FairTest, the National Center for Fair and Open Testing, more than 275 colleges and universities nationwide have moved to a test-optional admissions policy in the belief that standardized tests, such as the SAT and ACT, are not appropriate gauges for academic merit. However, there are still issues being debated among educators, admissions officers and administrators, including the impact on a school's image, logistical challenges and the effect on students' academic behavior.

View popular schools

By Mercy McKee

test

Find schools that offer these popular programs

  • Agriculture
  • Architecture
  • Biological and Biomedical Sciences
  • Business
  • Communications and Journalism
  • Computer Sciences
  • Culinary Arts and Personal Services
  • Education
  • Engineering
  • Legal
  • Liberal Arts and Humanities
  • Mechanic and Repair Technologies
  • Medical and Health Professions
  • Physical Sciences
  • Psychology
  • Transportation and Distribution
  • Visual and Performing Arts

Idealistic Move for Students or Marketing Gimmick for Schools?

FairTest, as well as many school administrators, believe that admissions policies should offer students both flexibility and the opportunity to show their academic and personal potential in a variety of ways, not just through test scores. Others, however, argue that dropping standardized tests from the admissions process is merely a marketing gimmick and deceptive strategy to improve rankings that has significant consequences. So what are the pros and cons of going test-optional?

The Argument for Test-Optional Admissions

One of the first arguments for taking test score requirements out of admissions is that there are more accurate predictors for college success than standardized tests. There have been studies that show that test results don't necessarily correlate to college success. Proponents of test-optional policies say that determining a student's academic merit should be based on their high school track record and their individual strengths and achievements rather than one afternoon of testing which may be more reflective of their family background than their academic capacity. Further, students may be encouraged to focus more on academics if they know they will be evaluated on their actual performance in the classroom rather than their SAT and ACT scores.

Additionally, performance on a test doesn't provide an accurate measure of some students' academic abilities. These students can be discouraged from applying to schools with SAT or ACT requirements and a student body with high averaging test scores. Removing the requirement may encourage low-scoring, yet otherwise academically strong students to apply to these schools, which can help colleges recruit academically stronger students, as well as diversify their student bodies.

Another concern is test coaching. Many students pay hundreds of dollars and spend countless hours on coaching courses in order to improve their test scores. However, admissions officers don't know which scores may have been boosted by coaching, and therefore don't know if the scores are representative of test-focused coaching or actual academic achievement.

Finally, SAT and ACT scores are currently used not only for college admissions, but also for awarding scholarships and measuring the quality of high schools, colleges and state education systems. However, experts and the test makers alike have said that judgments based on test score averages cannot be completely representative due to varying student populations and the proportion of students taking the tests.

Concerns and Criticisms

Opponents of test-optional admissions say that having test score requirements in place implies academic seriousness. There are concerns that removing them may signal a lowering of standards, which in turn may deter well-prepared students.

Artificial score inflation is another concern. If schools do not require test scores from lower-scoring applicants, and thereby do not report those scores, their test score average gives the appearance of increasing when it really hasn't. This may discourage lower income students from applying to schools they think are more academically prestigious than they really are.

And of course, there are logistical challenges. The biggest obstacle is making the switch to test-optional a priority in the face of hard economic times and bigger problems. Another hurdle is developing a national method for reporting scores, whether or not the scores are used in the admissions process. And finally, new policies and procedures would need to be developed and executed, and that takes time, faculty and money.

A test-optional admissions policy is just one factor in choosing a college. Read why students chose their school.

Next: View Schools

What is your highest level of education?

Some College
Complete your degree or find the graduate program that's right for you.
High School Diploma
Explore schools that offer bachelor and associate degrees.
Still in High School
Earn your diploma or GED. Plan your undergraduate education.

Schools you may like:

Popular Schools

The listings below may include sponsored content but are popular choices among our users.

    • Master of Science in Nursing - Doctor of Nursing Practice Path, Executive Leader Specialization
    • Doctor of Nursing Practice
    • Master of Science in Nursing - Doctor of Nursing Practice Path
    • Master of Science in Legal Studies
    • MS in Psychology
    • MBA
    • Master of Public Health
    • MBA - Human Resources
    • MBA - Health Care Management
    • BS in Liberal Studies
    • BS in Business Administration
    • Bachelor of Science in Business Administration, Investment Career Focus Area
    • BS in Liberal Studies Leadership
    • BS in Nutrition Science
    • BSFIN in Accelerated MS Finance
    • AAS in Business Administration - Business
    • AAS in Legal Support and Services
    • AAS in Business Administration
    • AAS in Business Administration - Food & Hotel Management
    • AAS in Business Admin-Office Management
    • AAS in Criminal Justice
    • Medical Office Administration Certificate
    • Human Services Certificates in Child and Family Services
    • Pathway to Paralegal Postbaccalaureate Certificate
    • Medical Billing and Coding Certificate
    • Family Nurse Practitioner Graduate Certificate
    • Executive Leader Graduate Certificate

    What is your highest level of education completed?

    • BA: Criminal Justice
    • BA: Criminal Justice - Criminalistics
    • BA: Liberal Studies
    • BA: Psychology
    • BA: Psychology - General
    • BS: Computer Science
    • AA: Criminal Justice
    • AA: Liberal Arts
    • AA: Business Administration
    • AA: Information Technology
    • AA: Cybersecurity

    What is your highest level of education completed?

    • MA in Communication
    • Master of Liberal Arts
    • MA in Science Writing
    • MS in Applied Economics
    • MS in Geographic Information Systems
    • MS in Bioinformatics

    What is your highest level of education?

    • Transitional Doctorate of Physical Therapy
    • MBA in Health Care Management
    • MBA in Finance/Accounting
    • MBA in General
    • MS in Healthcare Administration
    • MA in Financial Crime and Compliance Management
    • MS in Data Science: Social Science Analytics
    • BS in Cybersecurity - Network Forensics and Intrusion Investigation
    • RN to BSN
    • BS in Cybersecurity - Cybercrime and Fraud Investigation
    • BS in Cybersecurity - Information Assurance
    • Bachelor of Science in Fraud and Financial Crime Investigation
    • BS in Fraud and Financial Crime Investigation - Financial Investigation

    What is your highest level of education completed?

    • MSHS Medical Laboratory Sciences
    • MSHS in Immunohematology and Biotechnology
    • MSHS in Molecular Diagnostic Sciences
    • MSHS in Translational Microbiology
    • MA in Education and Human Development in Secondary Special Education and Transition Services
    • MA in Education and Human Development in Special Education for Culturally and Linguistically Diverse Learners
    • BSHS in Clinical Operations and Healthcare Management
    • BSHS in Medical Laboratory Sciences
    • BSHS in Biomedical Informatics

    What is your highest level of education?

    • Master of Professional Studies in Cybersecurity Management
    • Master of Professional Studies in Information Technology Management

    What is your highest level of education completed?

    • Master of Arts in Strategic Communication
    • Master of Arts in Strategic Communication - Advocacy and Social Impact Concentration
    • Master of Arts in Economics
    • Master of Public Administration and Policy
    • Master of Science in Agile Project Management
    • Master of Science in Healthcare Management

    What is your highest level of education?

    • Doctor of Business Administration - Management
    • Doctor of Nursing Practice (DNP)
    • EdD in Organizational Leadership - Health Care Administration
    • EdD in Organizational Leadership - Special Education
    • Ph.D. in General Psychology - Cognition and Instruction
    • Ph.D. in General Psychology - Industrial and Organizational Psychology
    • M.S. Psychology with an Emphasis in Gerontology
    • M.S. in Psychology with an Emphasis in Human Factors
    • MA in Curriculum and Instruction
    • MS in Criminal Justice: Legal Studies
    • MS in Psychology: General Psychology
    • M.A. in Communication with an Emphasis in Education
    • Bachelor of Science in Business for Secondary Education
    • BS in Psychology
    • B.S. in Psychology with an Emphasis in Performance and Sports Psychology
    • Bachelor of Science in Elementary Education
    • BS in Early Childhood
    • BS in Elementary Education / Special Education (Dual Major)

    What is your highest level of education?

    • Master of Science in Finance
    • Masters of Professional Studies in Technology Management
    • Master of Professional Studies in Real Estate

    What is your highest level of education completed?

    • Master of Science in Accounting
    • Master of Public Administration in Non-Profit Management
    • Master of Business Administration
    • Master of Business Administration - Accounting
    • Master of Business Administration - Finance
    • Master of Business Administration - Marketing

    What is your highest level of education?

Find your perfect school

What is your highest level of education?