Kyoto Protocol Overview, Pros, & Cons
What is the Kyoto Protocol?
Climate change remains one of the leading global concerns. In response to the existential threat caused by climate change, countries, governments, and multinational organizations have developed international measures and frameworks to combat the problem. The most important framework is the Kyoto Protocol.
What is Kyoto Protocol? It is an international environmental agreement enforced in 2005. 192 major promoters of this treaty aimed to curb the impact of climate change caused by human activities. The Kyoto Protocol operationalized global action against climate change by obliging signatories to limit greenhouse gas emissions. Each signatory is required to reduce the emission of carbon dioxide by adhering to agreed targets. Generally, the international treaty requests industrialized and emerging economies that have signed the convention to adopt and report their mitigation measures against climate change.
The Kyoto Protocol recognizes developed countries such as the US, European countries, and China as predominantly responsible for the high levels of atmospheric greenhouse gases. A major contributing industry is the automobile sector. Cars that rely on fossil fuels account for a large proportion of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere. The treaty binds 37 countries to individual targets in reducing carbon emissions. Parties to the international agreement are required to deposit instruments of acceptance in every commitment period. The protocol attempts to mobilize global communities towards achieving the common goal of addressing climate change.
What Is the Kyoto Protocol?
The Kyoto Protocol is the international agreement between industrialized nations to lower greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. It is named after Kyoto, Japan, where the agreement was drawn up in 1997 at the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC). Now that we know what the protocol was, let's take a closer look at what it was attempting to address.
Kyoto Protocol Provisions
Kyoto Protocol 1997 was named after the Japanese city where it was enforced in 1997. In full, the treaty is known as the Kyoto Protocol to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change. Specifically, the Kyoto climate provisions seek to reduce greenhouse emissions below 1990's levels. The treaty is widely recognized as the most important environmental agreement ever enacted. Nonetheless, critics continue to question its practicality and effectiveness, which explains why some countries are reluctant to follow the treaty fully.
According to the provisions, signatories must develop and enforce national programs designed to reduce their atmospheric carbon footprint. Applicable policies of the treaty target the reduction of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases such as sulfur hexafluoride, nitrous oxide, and methane. The Kyoto Protocol also targets a reduction of hydrofluorocarbons and perfluorocarbons in the atmosphere. According to the scientific mechanics underlining the protocol, high levels of these greenhouse gases result in a global increase in average temperatures. This phenomenon is called global warming. The increase in global average temperatures is caused by imbalanced atmospheric energy due to high levels of carbon, methane, and other greenhouse gases.
The Kyoto Protocol provisions are justified by scientific studies on the impact of global warming. According to existing research, continued global warming will have adverse long-term environmental implications, including:
- A global rise in sea levels that will result in the disappearance of islands and coastal regions.
- The melting of glaciers and Arctic ice.
- Earthquakes, floods, droughts and other extreme weather events will become more frequent and severe.
- Mass extinction of animal and plant species.
Fifty-five nations were required to ratify the agreement and enforce provisions for reducing emissions. The provisions established a framework that enforces emission reduction targets specific to each signatory. Generally, the provisions oblige countries to plant more trees to trap and recycle atmospheric carbon. The Clean Development Mechanism was also proposed in the provisions. This mechanism encourages countries to invest in green technology. For example, investing in natural gas will provide clean energy as an alternative to coal power.
The provisions also placed an economic consequence for failure to meet national commitments. Countries that failed to reduce their emissions as agreed are heavily penalized to inspire compliance with the treaty. Nonetheless, some countries like China remain reluctant to fully adopt the treaty because of its impact on economic activity. These countries are skeptical of key provisions that limit their industrial capacity, making them less competitive. Developing countries like India and China consider criticisms of their energy policies as unfair because they are heavily reliant on industrialization. The countries also argue that developed countries have a bigger carbon footprint because their emissions have accumulated over many years.
Positive Aspects of the Treaty
How is the Kyoto Protocol enforced? The Marrakesh Accords established the treaty's compliance system. A compliance committee facilitates and enforces compliance with the underlying provisions. Positive aspects of the international treaty that form a counterbalance to the economic activities that cause climate change include:
- Improved compliance with laws and policies designed to protect the environment and ecosystems.
- The Kyoto Protocol fuels innovations in the clean energy sector as countries seek alternative clean energy sources. Innovations such as geothermal and solar energy are replacing environmentally destructive coal and fossil fuels.
- The treaty has increased global awareness of the impacts of climate change.
Negative Aspects of the Treaty
Despite its apparent positive aspects, the Kyoto Protocol has compromised business interests. The international agreement significantly reduced corporate profits by limiting industrial capacities, especially in developing countries. The United States, under President George W. Bush, demonstrated more concern for business interests by refusing to sign the agreement. The president and other business leaders were myopic because they were only concerned with profits instead of human survival. As a result, they opposed US Kyoto Protocol participation in favor of business interests.
Business interests in the energy and automobile sectors have also been disrupted by the increased preference and investment in green energy. Traditional sources of energy, such as fossil fuels, face increased competition from alternative energy sources such as solar power and electricity. Electric-powered cars are expected to dominate the market in the future, spelling doom for fuel-based automobiles.
Lesson Summary
The Kyoto Protocol is an international agreement established to combat climate change, the shift in weather patterns due to long-term rise in global temperatures. Specifically, the treaty seeks to reduce greenhouse gas emissions such as carbon dioxide and methane. These emissions are directly linked to global warming, an increase in average global temperatures. The automobile sector is the main contributor to climate change due to cars relying on fossil fuels. The Kyoto climate provisions seek to reduce greenhouse emissions below 1990's levels. As such, signatories are obliged to develop and implement national programs that will reduce their carbon footprint.
Fifty-five countries were required to enforce the Kyoto Protocol provisions. Notable positive aspects of the treaty facilitated and enforced by the Marrakesh Accords include improved compliance with environmental protection policies and innovations in green energy. Green energy is renewable and is sourced from natural sources such as wind and sun. Nonetheless, negative aspects such as compromising business interests fueled opposition and criticism. Under President George W. Bush, the U.S. refused to sign the agreement out of fear of negatively impacting business interests. Nevertheless, Kyoto Protocol 1997 is widely recognized as the most important environmental agreement.
Greenhouse Gases
According to the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), greenhouse gas emission occurs as a result of human activities. GHG is the emission of any gaseous substance that inhibits the release of heat from the atmosphere, causing temperatures to rise at the earth's surface and ultimately, causing the occurrence of extreme weather for extended periods of time.
Many reports point to the burning of fossil fuels as a large source of GHGs. What does this mean? What is humanity's role in creating GHGs? When fossil fuels are burned they produce energy, which is used for such things as electricity or fuel. So, when it is said that GHGs are caused as a result of human activity, it could be caused from something as simple as driving to work. How many times have you driven to work, school, or your local park just in the last week?
Now, imagine millions of other people doing the same thing. Add millions of other activities that require electricity or fuel into the GHG equation and you have a big problem. The Kyoto Protocol is the United Nations' attempt to address this issue. The Kyoto Protocol is mainly concerned with six GHGs:
- Carbon dioxide
- Methane
- Sulfur hexafluoride
- Nitrous oxide
- Penfluorocarbons
- Hydrofluorocarbons
Kyoto Protocol Conditions
There were two conditions that the United Nations insisted on for the ratification of the Kyoto Protocol. The first condition was that at least 55 industrialized nations needed to sign the agreement. The second condition was that the nations that signed the agreement had to account for at least 55% of the world's emissions. The Kyoto Protocol was scheduled to be in effect 90 days after the conditions were met.
The first condition was satisfied when Iceland signed the agreement on May 23, 2002. The second condition was satisfied when Russia signed the agreement in November of 2004. The Kyoto Protocol went into effect on February 16, 2005. Each nation that signed the agreement had individual targets to lower their emissions by. The Kyoto Protocol set an overall target to lower GHG emissions by 5.2 percent of the 1990 GHG emissions between the periods of 2008 to 2012.
Pros and Cons
There has been a lot of debate regarding the pros and cons of the Kyoto Protocol since it was first developed. It should be noted that the United States did not sign the agreement. The president at the time, President George W. Bush, objected to the agreement for several reasons. The first reason was that developing nations were not included in the agreement and were considered to be exempt. Second, he felt that signing the agreement would negatively impact the United States economy and its growth.
Some people felt that the changes that the Kyoto Protocol asked nations to make acted as a catalyst in sparking business innovation, which in turn, positively aided economies. There was also a debate over whether or not the agreement actually made a difference in lowering GHG emissions since the biggest GHG contributors, the United States and China, were not part of the agreement. China is a developing nation and was not asked to sign the agreement.
Lesson Summary
Let's take a moment or two to review! The Kyoto Protocol is an international agreement requiring its signatories to reduce GHG emissions. Greenhouse gas emission is the emission of any gaseous substance that inhibits the release of heat from the atmosphere, causing temperatures to rise at the earth's surface and ultimately, causing the occurrence of extreme weather for extended periods of time.
The Kyoto Protocol focuses on six GHGs as their main concern:
- Carbon dioxide
- Methane
- Sulfur hexafluoride
- Nitrous oxide
- Penfluorocarbons
- Hydrofluorocarbons
There were two conditions that needed to be met before the Kyoto Protocol would take effect.
- Fifty-five nations needed to sign the agreement
- The nations that signed needed to account for 55% of GHG emissions worldwide.
Pros and Cons of the Kyoto Protocol are:
- Pro - It sparked business innovation.
- Con - It placed an economic burden on some nations, including two of the greatest contributors of greenhouse gases: The United States and China.
To unlock this lesson you must be a Study.com Member.
Create your account
What Is the Kyoto Protocol?
The Kyoto Protocol is the international agreement between industrialized nations to lower greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. It is named after Kyoto, Japan, where the agreement was drawn up in 1997 at the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC). Now that we know what the protocol was, let's take a closer look at what it was attempting to address.
Greenhouse Gases
According to the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), greenhouse gas emission occurs as a result of human activities. GHG is the emission of any gaseous substance that inhibits the release of heat from the atmosphere, causing temperatures to rise at the earth's surface and ultimately, causing the occurrence of extreme weather for extended periods of time.
Many reports point to the burning of fossil fuels as a large source of GHGs. What does this mean? What is humanity's role in creating GHGs? When fossil fuels are burned they produce energy, which is used for such things as electricity or fuel. So, when it is said that GHGs are caused as a result of human activity, it could be caused from something as simple as driving to work. How many times have you driven to work, school, or your local park just in the last week?
Now, imagine millions of other people doing the same thing. Add millions of other activities that require electricity or fuel into the GHG equation and you have a big problem. The Kyoto Protocol is the United Nations' attempt to address this issue. The Kyoto Protocol is mainly concerned with six GHGs:
- Carbon dioxide
- Methane
- Sulfur hexafluoride
- Nitrous oxide
- Penfluorocarbons
- Hydrofluorocarbons
Kyoto Protocol Conditions
There were two conditions that the United Nations insisted on for the ratification of the Kyoto Protocol. The first condition was that at least 55 industrialized nations needed to sign the agreement. The second condition was that the nations that signed the agreement had to account for at least 55% of the world's emissions. The Kyoto Protocol was scheduled to be in effect 90 days after the conditions were met.
The first condition was satisfied when Iceland signed the agreement on May 23, 2002. The second condition was satisfied when Russia signed the agreement in November of 2004. The Kyoto Protocol went into effect on February 16, 2005. Each nation that signed the agreement had individual targets to lower their emissions by. The Kyoto Protocol set an overall target to lower GHG emissions by 5.2 percent of the 1990 GHG emissions between the periods of 2008 to 2012.
Pros and Cons
There has been a lot of debate regarding the pros and cons of the Kyoto Protocol since it was first developed. It should be noted that the United States did not sign the agreement. The president at the time, President George W. Bush, objected to the agreement for several reasons. The first reason was that developing nations were not included in the agreement and were considered to be exempt. Second, he felt that signing the agreement would negatively impact the United States economy and its growth.
Some people felt that the changes that the Kyoto Protocol asked nations to make acted as a catalyst in sparking business innovation, which in turn, positively aided economies. There was also a debate over whether or not the agreement actually made a difference in lowering GHG emissions since the biggest GHG contributors, the United States and China, were not part of the agreement. China is a developing nation and was not asked to sign the agreement.
Lesson Summary
Let's take a moment or two to review! The Kyoto Protocol is an international agreement requiring its signatories to reduce GHG emissions. Greenhouse gas emission is the emission of any gaseous substance that inhibits the release of heat from the atmosphere, causing temperatures to rise at the earth's surface and ultimately, causing the occurrence of extreme weather for extended periods of time.
The Kyoto Protocol focuses on six GHGs as their main concern:
- Carbon dioxide
- Methane
- Sulfur hexafluoride
- Nitrous oxide
- Penfluorocarbons
- Hydrofluorocarbons
There were two conditions that needed to be met before the Kyoto Protocol would take effect.
- Fifty-five nations needed to sign the agreement
- The nations that signed needed to account for 55% of GHG emissions worldwide.
Pros and Cons of the Kyoto Protocol are:
- Pro - It sparked business innovation.
- Con - It placed an economic burden on some nations, including two of the greatest contributors of greenhouse gases: The United States and China.
To unlock this lesson you must be a Study.com Member.
Create your account
Why was the Kyoto Protocol created?
The Kyoto Protocol was created to curb the impact of climate change caused by human activities. The agreement required signatories to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.
What are the key points of the Kyoto Protocol?
The Kyoto Protocol is an international treaty aiming to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. Its key points include an obligation for signatories to implement national programs for reducing greenhouse gas emissions. Furthermore, the provisions placed an economic consequence for countries that failed to fulfill their commitments.
Is the Kyoto Protocol still active?
The Kyoto Protocol lacked an effective enforcement mechanism. Coupled with opposition from business leaders and the U.S., it lacked support. In 2012, the treaty officially expired.
Register to view this lesson
Unlock Your Education
See for yourself why 30 million people use Study.com
Become a Study.com member and start learning now.
Become a MemberAlready a member? Log In
BackResources created by teachers for teachers
I would definitely recommend Study.com to my colleagues. It’s like a teacher waved a magic wand and did the work for me. I feel like it’s a lifeline.