The XYZ Affair and Early American Diplomacy

Nathan Murphy, Amy Lively
  • Author
    Nathan Murphy

    Nathan Murphy received his B.A. in History at the California State University in Long Beach.

  • Instructor
    Amy Lively

    Amy has an M.A. in American History. She has taught history at all levels, from university to middle school.

Learn about the cause of the XYZ Affair. Discover the historical context that led to the affair. Explore the XYZ Affair's significance, how it was resolved, and it's relationship to the Quasi War. Updated: 10/08/2021

What Was the XYZ Affair?

The XYZ Affair refers to a diplomatic mission between French and American diplomats. European countries, especially France and Great Britain, were often involved in some war or conflict. Because of this, President George Washington established the principle of American neutrality. The United States was not going to involve itself in the countless European wars which surely would occur in the coming decades and centuries.

By the time John Adams became the second president, Great Britain and France were at war again and Adams adhered to Washington's guidance and refused to involve the young nation. The United States continued to trade with both countries even while they fought each other. However, the French government did not think the United States should be trading with the British and this was the central issue of the affair.

John Adams was Washingtons Vice President and tried to carry on his legacy

XYZ Affair: Date

The XYZ Affair's date is 1797, when John Adams sent three diplomats to France in hopes of finding a peaceful remedy to the rise in tensions.

  • November 19, 1794: The U.S. and Great Britain signed the Jay Treaty, which began a positive relationship between the two countries.
  • May 16, 1797: John Adams gave a speech calling for the United States to prepare for a potential war with France.
  • October 14, 1797: American diplomats are bribed by the French government and send news back to the President.

Definition

The XYZ Affair was a diplomatic incident that occurred between the United States and France in 1797. In an attempt to avert war with Great Britain, the U.S. signed the Jay Treaty in 1795. One of the provisions of the treaty limited the ability of nations that were hostile to Great Britain to trade in U.S. ports. Great Britain and France were at war and therefore, France was considered a hostile nation. France retaliated by seizing American ships. Attempts at negotiating a compromise with France failed when American diplomats refused to pay money to meet with French Foreign Minister Talleyrand.

An error occurred trying to load this video.

Try refreshing the page, or contact customer support.

Coming up next: What is the Alien Act of 1798? - Definition & Overview

You're on a roll. Keep up the good work!

Take Quiz Watch Next Lesson
 Replay
Your next lesson will play in 10 seconds
  • 0:00 Definition
  • 0:40 The Role Of The Jay Treaty
  • 1:35 Failed Negotiations…
  • 2:40 French-American Quasi War
  • 3:30 The Significance Of…
  • 4:35 Lesson Summary
Save Save Save

Want to watch this again later?

Log in or sign up to add this lesson to a Custom Course.

Log in or Sign up

Timeline
Autoplay
Autoplay
Speed Speed

XYZ Affair: Summary

The French monarchy had financially and militarily supported the colonists during the American Revolution and went deeply into debt as a result of that support. This debt, plus excessive spending by the French King and Queen, meant that common people had to pay an increasingly large amount of taxes. By 1789, unrest about taxes and a desire for a representative government led people to rise up and establish their own government. This began the French Revolution and within years the new government executed the monarchs and began to transform French society. However, other European monarchs like King George III were not happy about the French Revolution, because if French subjects could overthrow the king of France, English subjects may be inspired to do the same to the English monarchy. This fear by monarchs resulted in the War of the First Coalition, in which leaders of Great Britain, Prussia, and Austria attempted to reinstall a monarchy, thereby bringing stability to their own empires.

What Caused the XYZ Affair?

During this period, the United States signed the Jay Treaty in 1794, which gave favored nation status to Great Britain. This status meant that they took precedent over all other nations when exporting goods overseas. With France in the midst of a revolution, and the United States making a trade deal with their enemy, French politicians felt betrayed. Thomas Jefferson and the Democrat-Republicans thought the country had an obligation to help France in their fight for democratic values, while Alexander Hamilton, John Adams, and the Federalists favored Great Britain and wanted to uphold the precedent of neutrality that Washington had established.

Washington set many of the precedents for presidents and American policies in general such as neutrality

By 1797, French ships had begun to board American ships and seize any goods that were bound for Great Britain. The French government recognized the U.S. was going to continue trading with the English and began to militarily prevent the flow of goods from across the Atlantic. John Adams sought to find a peaceful resolution to this aggression. However, he also called for the American military to prepare for a French invasion of the American coast.

What Happened in the XYZ Affair?

After giving a speech to Congress calling for war preparations, John Adams began to organize a diplomatic mission to France in which three Americans would attempt to negotiate with the French government.

In July of 1797, John Marshall, Thomas Pickney, and Elbridge Gerry sailed for France and arrived at the beginning of October. The Americans were due to negotiate with one of the most prolific French statesmen, Charles Talleyrand. However, before meeting with him, three French diplomats began the negotiations and exposed the true goals of the French. The French diplomats Bellamy, Hottinguer, and Hauteval notified the Americans that if they wanted to negotiate with Talleyrand, the American government would have to give France a low-interest loan and pay Talleyrand a massive bribe. Only if those conditions were met could real negotiations commence.

Talleyrand served across several French governments into the 1830s

Upon learning about these demands, the diplomats sent a letter back home to Adams to notify him of this bribery request. When Adams received the letter months later, he announced that the diplomatic mission had failed. However, Jefferson, who supported France, did not believe this and wanted the letter released so everyone could read it. Jefferson continually supported France throughout his career, and even made excuses for the French government during this affair. John Adams complied because he knew what was in the letter, and the only change he made was removing the names of the three French diplomats in case they continued to negotiate on behalf of the French government. He replaced their names with X, Y, and Z, and that is where the affair gets its name.

What Was the Impact of the XYZ Affair?

The impact of the XYZ Affair was that much of the country supported John Adams and his calls for military preparedness. By 1798, relations between the two countries deteriorated so much that a 'half war' began. Because the French continued to board American ships, and after the insult of the requested bribery, the United States navy began to attack French ships in the Caribbean and along the American east coast. This was done largely to protect the merchant ships that were threatened by French ships.

This was the United States first undeclared war, however, it would not be the last.

This was called the Quasi-War and spanned two years from 1798-1800. All-out war was feared so much at the time that George Washington reluctantly agreed to come out of retirement if the French invaded the United States.

The Role of the Jay Treaty

George Washington signed the Jay Treaty in 1795 because he was trying to prevent another war with Great Britain. Both countries had grievances, but one of the primary issues was centered on Great Britain's war with France. Britain did not permit France to trade with neutral nations, such as the United States. Britain believed it had the right to seize American ships en route to France. U.S. ships headed to France with food were forced into British ports. Goods were taken, and American seamen were forced to serve in the British Royal Navy.

President Washington sent John Jay to England in 1794 to negotiate a compromise with British foreign secretary Lord William Grenville. The Jay Treaty, as we already learned, limited France's ability to trade in U.S. ports. It did not solve all of our country's problems with Great Britain, but it did prevent a war. Unfortunately, France did not like the terms, which created a whole new problem for the U.S.

Failed Negotiations with France

France and the U.S. had been on good terms since the Revolutionary War. In fact, without French troops and money, the U.S. probably would've lost. So, when the U.S. agreed as part of the Jay Treaty to limit France's access to American seaports, France was offended and sought revenge by seizing American ships.

President John Adams sent Elbridge Gerry, John Marshall, and Charles Pinckney to Paris in 1797 to negotiate a compromise. However, negotiations failed when three French agents met with the Americans instead of French Foreign Minister Talleyrand. They said if the Americans wanted to see Talleyrand, the U.S. had to give France a loan and add in a little extra just for Talleyrand. Without it, the French said, there could be a war. Adams read Marshall's dispatches from Paris and started preparing for war because there would be no money changing hands.

French-American Quasi War

Some members of the Democratic-Republican Party did not trust Adams, a Federalist. They wanted to see Marshall's dispatches for themselves. Adams released the documents, with X, Y, and Z inserted in place of the names of the French agents. When word spread about how France had treated the American diplomats, many Americans were so angry that they were ready to go to war.

The French-American Quasi War began, meaning there was no official declaration of war. However, French and American ships did battle in the Caribbean. Talleyrand realized the error of his ways and reopened negotiations. Congress did agree to try to renegotiate, but it was not until Napoleon took over the French government in 1799 that the fighting ended. The Treaty of Mortefontaine was signed on September 30, 1800, and the U.S. and France restored their trade and diplomatic relationships.

Significance of the XYZ Affair

The XYZ Affair had a lasting impact on the U.S., even after peace was restored. The U.S. was not at all prepared for a naval battle, so the Department of the Navy was created in 1798 to oversee all naval affairs. Negative feelings about France resulted in the Alien and Sedition Acts in 1798. The laws increased the residency requirement for U.S. citizenship, restricted anti-government speech, and allowed for the deportation or imprisonment of 'dangerous' immigrants.

To unlock this lesson you must be a Study.com Member.
Create your account

Video Transcript

Definition

The XYZ Affair was a diplomatic incident that occurred between the United States and France in 1797. In an attempt to avert war with Great Britain, the U.S. signed the Jay Treaty in 1795. One of the provisions of the treaty limited the ability of nations that were hostile to Great Britain to trade in U.S. ports. Great Britain and France were at war and therefore, France was considered a hostile nation. France retaliated by seizing American ships. Attempts at negotiating a compromise with France failed when American diplomats refused to pay money to meet with French Foreign Minister Talleyrand.

The Role of the Jay Treaty

George Washington signed the Jay Treaty in 1795 because he was trying to prevent another war with Great Britain. Both countries had grievances, but one of the primary issues was centered on Great Britain's war with France. Britain did not permit France to trade with neutral nations, such as the United States. Britain believed it had the right to seize American ships en route to France. U.S. ships headed to France with food were forced into British ports. Goods were taken, and American seamen were forced to serve in the British Royal Navy.

President Washington sent John Jay to England in 1794 to negotiate a compromise with British foreign secretary Lord William Grenville. The Jay Treaty, as we already learned, limited France's ability to trade in U.S. ports. It did not solve all of our country's problems with Great Britain, but it did prevent a war. Unfortunately, France did not like the terms, which created a whole new problem for the U.S.

Failed Negotiations with France

France and the U.S. had been on good terms since the Revolutionary War. In fact, without French troops and money, the U.S. probably would've lost. So, when the U.S. agreed as part of the Jay Treaty to limit France's access to American seaports, France was offended and sought revenge by seizing American ships.

President John Adams sent Elbridge Gerry, John Marshall, and Charles Pinckney to Paris in 1797 to negotiate a compromise. However, negotiations failed when three French agents met with the Americans instead of French Foreign Minister Talleyrand. They said if the Americans wanted to see Talleyrand, the U.S. had to give France a loan and add in a little extra just for Talleyrand. Without it, the French said, there could be a war. Adams read Marshall's dispatches from Paris and started preparing for war because there would be no money changing hands.

French-American Quasi War

Some members of the Democratic-Republican Party did not trust Adams, a Federalist. They wanted to see Marshall's dispatches for themselves. Adams released the documents, with X, Y, and Z inserted in place of the names of the French agents. When word spread about how France had treated the American diplomats, many Americans were so angry that they were ready to go to war.

The French-American Quasi War began, meaning there was no official declaration of war. However, French and American ships did battle in the Caribbean. Talleyrand realized the error of his ways and reopened negotiations. Congress did agree to try to renegotiate, but it was not until Napoleon took over the French government in 1799 that the fighting ended. The Treaty of Mortefontaine was signed on September 30, 1800, and the U.S. and France restored their trade and diplomatic relationships.

Significance of the XYZ Affair

The XYZ Affair had a lasting impact on the U.S., even after peace was restored. The U.S. was not at all prepared for a naval battle, so the Department of the Navy was created in 1798 to oversee all naval affairs. Negative feelings about France resulted in the Alien and Sedition Acts in 1798. The laws increased the residency requirement for U.S. citizenship, restricted anti-government speech, and allowed for the deportation or imprisonment of 'dangerous' immigrants.

To unlock this lesson you must be a Study.com Member.
Create your account

Frequently Asked Questions

What did the XYZ Affair cause?

The XYZ Affair caused heightened tensions between the United States and France. This resulted in the Quasi-War which was the U.S.'s attempt to prevent France from confiscating more goods bound for Great Britain.

What was the XYZ Affair in simple terms?

The XYZ Affair was a failed negotiation attempt between the United States and the revolutionary new French government which needed money during its defensive war with Great Britain. This led French diplomats to ask for money before negotiations even could begin. The Adams Administration instantly refused this proposal.

Why did they call it XYZ Affair?

It was called the XYZ Affair because John Adams released the letter sent by American diplomats but redacted the names of the French diplomats in case they participated in the negotiations again. Their names were replaced with X, Y, and Z.

How did the XYZ Affair affect the US?

The XYZ Affair effected the United States because American merchants continued to lose money from confiscated goods. It also heightened partisan divide between Federalists and Democrat-Republicans who disagreed over giving support to the French cause.

Register to view this lesson

Are you a student or a teacher?

Unlock Your Education

See for yourself why 30 million people use Study.com

Become a Study.com member and start learning now.
Become a Member  Back

Resources created by teachers for teachers

Over 30,000 video lessons & teaching resources‐all in one place.
Video lessons
Quizzes & Worksheets
Classroom Integration
Lesson Plans

I would definitely recommend Study.com to my colleagues. It’s like a teacher waved a magic wand and did the work for me. I feel like it’s a lifeline.

Jennifer B.
Teacher
Jennifer B.
Create an account to start this course today
Used by over 30 million students worldwide
Create an account